

| Sarah, Plain and Tall | 2002 | Original Off-Broadway Cast |
Note: this song may also appear on other recordings whose tracks have not yet been indexed.
| Cow Pond | ||
| Dinner Song | ||
| Don't Miss the Sea | ||
| Finale | ||
| Is It Me You Want to Kiss? | ||
| Letters | ||
| Quartet | ||
| Sarah, Plain and Tall | ||
| Sing You to Sleep | ||
| Sixty Cents | ||
| Storm | ||
| Would You Miss Me? |