| Song Title | Source | Composer(s) |
| My Love Has Gone Away | Tom Sawyer
| Luther |
| My Love Is All Madness And Folly | Beggar's Opera, The
| Gay |
| My Love Is Like a Butterfly | Cyrano
| Shire |
| My Love Is on the Way | Golden Apple, The
| Moross |
| My Love Is Yours | Student Gypsy, The
| Besoyan |
| My Love Parade | Love Parade, The
| Schertzinger |
| My Love Will Come by | Ballad for Bimshire
| Burgie |
| My Love, My Love | Awakening, The
| Schocker |
| My Lovely Wooden Box | Flute Player's Song, The
| Troy |
| My Lover Is a Scoundrel | Pleasures and Palaces
| Loesser |
| My Lovey-Dovey Baby | Newsies
| Menken |
| My Luck Is Changing | Tap Dance Kid, The
| Krieger |
| My Lucky Star | Good News!
| Henderson |
| My Lucky Star | One Dam Thing After Another
| Rodgers |
| My Lullaby | Lion King 2: Simba's Pride, The
| Mancina, Snow, Quinn, Petersen, Warrender |
| My Magic Lamp | Kismet
| Borodin |
| My Maker | Jane Eyre
| Gordon |
| My Mammy | Rose of Washington Square
| various |
| My Mammy | Jolson
| various |
| My Man | Funny Girl
| Styne |
| My Man | Rose of Washington Square
| various |
| My Man | Ziegfeld
| various |
| My Man | Great Ziegfeld, The
| various |
| My Man (Mon Homme) | Lady Sings the Blues
| various |
| My Man Blues | One Mo' Time
| various |
| My Man Is Good for Nothing but Love | Hot Chocolates
| Brooks, Waller |
| My Man Rocks Me | It Ain't Nothin' But the Blues
| various |
| My Man Sends Me | My People
| Ellington |
| My Man's Gone Now | Porgy and Bess
| Gershwin |
| My Master Plan | Ballad for Bimshire
| Burgie |
| My Melancholy Baby | Billy Rose's Diamond Horseshoe
| Warren |
| My Melancholy Baby | Helen Morgan Story, The
| various |
| My Melancholy Baby | Star Is Born, A
| Arlen |
| My Mind on Freedom | Jericho-Jim Crow
| various |
| My Miss Mary | Tenderloin
| Bock |
| My Missus | Betsy
| Rodgers |
| My Most Important Moments Go by | Last Sweet Days Of Isaac, The
| Ford |
| My Most Intimate Friend | Jubilee
| Porter |
| My Mother | Secret Garden, The
| Burgett |
| My Mother Bore Me | Phantom
| Yeston |
| My Mother Said | Inner City
| Miller |
| My Mother Told Me | Two Girls and a Sailor
| various |
| My Mother Was a Fortune Teller | Madwoman Of Central Park West, The
| Clifton |
| My Mother Would Love You | Panama Hattie
| Porter |
| My Mother's Eyes | Jersey Boys
| various, Gaudio |
| My Mother's Wedding Day | Brigadoon
| Loewe |
| My Mother, My Father (Heritage) | My People
| Ellington |
| My Mothers Always Said | Mimi Le Duck
| Feinstein |
| My Motter | Arcadians, The
| Monckton, Talbot |
| My Name | Bed & Sofa
| Pen |