| Song Title | Source | Composer(s) |
|---|
| Proposal | Captive
| Collister |
| Proposal Duet | Sherry!
| Rosenthal |
| Proposal Rehearsal | Main-Travelled Roads
| Libman |
| Proposal, The | Titanic
| Yeston |
| Proposal, The | Jane Eyre
| Gordon |
| Propriedad del Reino Vegetal, La | ¡Que planton!
| Mendez |
| Propsal Duet/Listen, Cosette, The | Sherry!
| Rosenthal |
| Prosecutor's Song | Passe-Muraille, Le
| Legrand |
| Protect Me | Inside U.S.A.
| Schwartz |
| Protection | Captive
| Collister |
| Protocoligorically Correct | Slipper and the Rose, The
| Sherman, Sherman |
| Prou! | Poe
| Roig |
| Proud As a Peacock | Cowboy And The Tiger, The
| Beebe |
| Proud Lady | Baker's Wife, The
| Schwartz |
| Proud Mary | Let's Pop
| various |
| Proud Mary | Beehive
| various |
| Proud of Your Boy | Aladdin
| Menken |
| Proud Round People | All About Love
| Arnest |
| Proud, Erstwhile, Upright, Fair | Utter Glory of Morrissey Hall, The
| Gesner |
| Prove I'm Really Here | Whispers on the Wind
| Crane |
| Provins Fair | Beauty and the Beast
| Blood |
| Prowlin' | Grease 2
| St. Louis, Bugatti, Musker, Linde, Hegel |
| Prozac, Ritalin, Trimspa | NEWSical: All the Stuff That's Fit to Spoof
| Crom |
| Pruebas | Aquí no podemos hacerlo
| Mahler, Serra |
| Psalm 8 | King David
| Menken |
| Psalm of Peace, A | Hard Job Being God
| Martel |
| Psalm, The | Man of La Mancha
| Leigh |
| Psychiatry Song, The | Johnny Johnson
| Weill |
| Psychological Approach | New Cranks
| Lee |
| Psychotic Overtures | Corkscrews
| Siegel |
| Puberty | Cleavage
| Sheffield |
| Public Enemy Number 1 | Das Barbecü
| Warrender |
| Public Enemy Number One | Anything Goes
| Porter |
| Public Library | New Cranks
| Lee |
| Public Relations | Don't Stop the Carnival
| Buffett |
| Public Relations (Reprise) | Don't Stop the Carnival
| Buffett |
| Pucks Schlaflied | Ein Sommernachtstraum - das Musical
| Lingnau |
| Puddles | Exchange
| Brandt, Knight, Lowery |
| Pudelballade | Minna. Musical
| Kemmer, Wecker |
| Pudgy Legs | Allegro
| Rodgers |
| Puede Ser Que Todo | Lovy: El Musical
| Gomez, Morato |
| Puedes Llegar a Coincidir | Cuando Harry encontro a Sally
| Vives |
| Puerto Rican Day Parade | Capeman, The
| Simon |
| Puffer's Confession | Mystery Of Edwin Drood, The
| Holmes |
| Puffer's Revelation | Mystery Of Edwin Drood, The
| Holmes |
| Puisque C'est Ma Rose | Le petit prince
| Cocciante |
| Puka Puka Pants | 13 Daughters
| Magoon |
| Pull Yourself Together | Trelawny
| Slade |
| Pullin' Together | Pull Both Ends
| King, Schroeder |
| Pump Boys | Pump Boys and Dinettes
| various |
